96 Points: Silverado Vineyards 2012 SOLO Cabernet Sauvignon -
Beautiful flavors of both red and black berries with notes
of violets and sweet spices. This Cabernet from Stags Leap
District is incredibly elegant, complex and balanced, and
this vintage is one to lay down for a few decades.
Just after the 2012 harvest in Napa Valley,
Bart Araujo, former owner of Araujo
Estate and now of Accendo Cellars, told
me the vintage might be the best for 20
years. “The weather was perfect and the fruit
was excellent,” he said. Araujo was not getting
carried away – his sentiments were echoed
across the valley.
Aron Weinkauf, winemaker of Spottswoode,
views 2012 is an “idyllic” vintage. “The growing
season was easy – there were no huge heat
spells, no challenging rain.” The only downside
was that it was arguably too easy. “The wines
are beautiful but perhaps not exciting,” he says.
Most winemakers disagree. Cathy Corison, of
Corison Wines, was grateful for the large crop
and calls the 2012 “perfect”. Ann Colgin of
Colgin Cellars is equally enthusiastic. “The 2012
vintage was a classic – it was generous and the
fruit was beautiful.”
A vintage will always be compared with
what preceded it, of course, and 2012 came
after the most challenging of vintages in Napa,
the 2011, with its cool temperatures, incessant
disease pressure and small volumes. 2012 had
ideal bud break and good flowering followed by
a long stretch of warm days and cool nights with
little rain. What more can a winemaker ask for?
Not only was 2012 a perfect growing season,
but it also yielded an abundant crop. Philippe
Bascaules, who has overseen a change in style
at Inglenook with grapes picked earlier and
fresher, was delighted. “Big crops in California
are good because they dilute the concentration
and produce better balanced wines,” he
explains. “We want to be the reference for
finesse and elegance in Napa.” Not all the
changes he has implemented are viticultural
though – Inglenook now pays pickers by the
hour rather than by the ton, as Bascaules
believes workers will be less inclined to rush
and over-load bins, crushing grapes.
Another French winemaker, Hélène
Mingot of Araujo Estate, reduced the output
of the Eisele Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon
from 2,000 cases to 1,700 in the abundant 2012
vintage, part of a long-term strategy for stricter
selection and greater quality. The evidence is
in the bottle – 2012 combines both elegance
and intensity. Others employed vineyard
CURRENT RELEASE
NAPA 2012
Blessed with a near-perfect growing season, the vintage
is shaping up to be just about as good as it gets.
techniques to keep quantity down. “The 2012
was a big crop,” says Tom Futo of Futo Wines.
“We worked hard in the vineyard – taking
off the shoulders, the large wings, and going
through cluster by cluster.” The hard work paid
off; Futo’s 2012 reds are fabulous.
The 2012 arrives at a time when many Napa
winemakers are looking for freshness and
balance. Michael Silacci, winemaker at Opus
One, says that since the 2009 vintage there
has been a distinct shift. Whereas in the past,
60-80 percent of the grapes harvested were
defined as having “ripe fruit”, with flavors
leaning toward dark, black fruits, now only
40 to 60 percent ripe fruit is desired, with the
rest made up of “fresh fruit”.
Because of the generous volumes, there
should be plenty of great wines at every price
point. Overall, this is classic Napa at its very
best. In the right hands, the wines strike that
perfect balance of generosity and intensity of
flavor; a firm backbone wrapped in plush, velvety
tannins; and wonderful freshness and length.